Advanced Analysis
Treatment detection and proportion analysis: the two areas of advanced gemmological assessment that require correlating multiple lines of evidence rather than reading a single instrument.
Treatment Detection
Visual & instrumental indicators for common gem treatments
Common Treatment Types
Heat Treatment
ModerateColour improvement, inclusion dissolving
Fracture Filling
EasyClarity enhancement
Dyeing
EasyColour enhancement
Oiling/Resin
ModerateClarity enhancement (especially emerald)
Irradiation
DifficultColour change (blue topaz, coloured diamonds)
Diffusion
ModerateColour enhancement
Coating
EasyColour, iridescence, or protective layer
HPHT
Very DifficultColour improvement (diamonds, synthetic gems)
Detection Indicators
| Treatment | Visual | Instrumental | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
Heat (Corundum) Ruby, Sapphire | Silk dissolution, rounded inclusions, colour zoning changes, stress fractures | Microscopy (inclusion changes), spectroscopy (Fe³⁺ peaks) | Permanent |
Beryllium Diffusion Sapphire (orange padparadscha) | Colour concentration at facet junctions, uneven colour | EDXRF (beryllium detection), FTIR, UV-Vis | Permanent |
Fracture Filling (Glass) Ruby, Diamond | Flash effect, colour flashes in fissures, surface residue | Microscopy (gas bubbles, flow structures) | Temporary |
Oiling (Emerald) Emerald | Oil in fissures (UV fluorescence), surface residue | UV lamp (yellow-green fluorescence), FTIR | Temporary |
Irradiation + Heat Blue Topaz, Fancy Diamonds | Uniform colour, specific colour types (Swiss/London blue) | Spectroscopy (radiation-induced defects), colour centres | Permanent |
Dyeing Jade, Chalcedony, Pearls | Colour in pores/fractures, unnatural colours, concentrations | Microscopy (dye concentrations), Chelsea filter, spectroscopy | Temporary |
Coating Topaz (Mystic), Diamond | Wear at facet edges, scratches revealing base colour | Microscopy (edge chipping), spectroscopy | Temporary |
Lattice Diffusion Sapphire (full colour) | Even colour distribution, possible surface concentration | EDXRF (Ti, Fe detection at surface), FTIR | Permanent |
Clarity Enhancement (Diamonds) Diamond | Flash effect in fractures, laser drill holes | Microscopy (drill holes, filler in fractures) | Temporary |
Treatment Wizard
Pick the gem kind, tick observed clues, get ranked treatment likelihoods
Pick the gem kind, tick the clues you actually see under loupe, microscope, UV, or warming. The wizard weighs each clue and ranks treatments by likelihood. A negative score means the clue argues against that treatment.
Observed clues (0 ticked of 12)
Proportion Analyser
Evaluate cut quality from proportion measurements
Cut Grade Reference
Excellent
Premium pricingProportions within ideal range, maximum brilliance and fire
Market Impact: Premium pricing - 10-20% above average cut
Very Good
Slight premiumProportions within acceptable range, excellent light performance
Market Impact: Slight premium - 5-10% above average cut
Good
Market average pricingProportions acceptable, good light return
Market Impact: Market average pricing
Fair
DiscountProportions outside ideal, noticeable light leakage
Market Impact: Discount - 10-20% below average cut
Poor
Heavy discountSevere proportion issues, significant windowing or extinction
Market Impact: Heavy discount - 30-50% below average cut
Proportion Analyser
⚠️ Important Notes
- • This is a simplified analysis - full cut grading requires symmetry, polish, and other factors
- • Colored gemstones have wider acceptable ranges than diamonds
- • Some cuts (antique cushions, Portuguese cuts) intentionally vary from modern standards
- • Professional cut grading requires calibrated proportionscopes and gemological training
Origin Determination
Geographic origin determination requires detailed knowledge of inclusion suites, trace element chemistry, and regional characteristics. See the learn section:
About these advanced tools & methodology
Treatment detection requires correlating multiple lines of evidence. Heat treatment in corundum leaves characteristic stress fractures around rutile inclusions and healed fingerprints, but not all heated stones show these features; a clean, well-heated stone may show no internal evidence at all. Fracture filling in emerald suppresses the fingerprint inclusions that would otherwise be visible under magnification, but the filling material itself can be identified by its flash effect and RI mismatch with the host. Diffusion treatment in sapphire concentrates colour at the surface, visible as concentrated colour at facet edges when the stone is immersed. Each treatment leaves a different combination of positive and negative evidence, and confident treatment assessment depends on accumulating independent observations rather than relying on any single clue.
The treatment wizard on this page formalises this evidence-accumulation approach. It covers 18 observable clues, including inclusion type, surface texture, colour distribution, spectral absorption anomalies, fluorescence pattern, and magnification features, mapped against 11 treatment categories: heat, fracture filling, surface coating, diffusion, irradiation, oiling, waxing, bleaching, impregnation, laser drilling, and flux healing. Each clue carries positive or negative evidence weights for each treatment type. Submit the clues you have observed and the wizard sums the weights per treatment, producing a confidence-banded conclusion: high confidence when three or more independent indicators align, low confidence when evidence is mixed or a single clue stands alone. This mirrors the reasoning process used in major gemmological laboratories and makes the logic explicit rather than implicit.
The proportion analyzer applies a different kind of multi-parameter assessment to cut quality in round brilliant diamonds. The GIA cut-grade system evaluates seven proportions independently: table percentage, total depth percentage, crown angle, pavilion angle, girdle thickness, culet size, and star length. Each parameter falls into one of five grade bands (Excellent, Very Good, Good, Fair, Poor) according to published GIA thresholds, and the overall cut grade is determined by the lowest-grading individual parameter. Enter the measured proportions from a proportion scope or grading report and the tool displays the per-parameter band for each value, highlights the limiting parameter, and returns the resulting cut grade. Understanding which proportion is pulling the grade down (crown angle too shallow, table too wide, or girdle too thick) gives a precise basis for cut-quality assessment and client communication.